Fasten Your Seat Belts
And so at last the year begins for the true fight fan, with two welterweight bouts of consequence tomorrow night involving two of the rising stars of the division.
The fight with the most immediate implications for future welterweight action is the headliner, where WBO champ Paul "The Punisher" Williams puts his belt on the line against Carlos Quintana, the belt that he won in a stunning, near-virtuoso performance against Antonio Margarito last summer. Tomorrow night's bout is most interesting as a litmus test for Williams that will tell us roughly where he stands in relation to Miguel Cotto, who won his WBA title against Quintana in December of 2006. That was Cotto's first bout at welterweight, and to put it mildly, it was no contest. He destroyed Quintana with his trademark body assault and forced his fellow Boricuan to quit on his stool after the fifth round.
Obviously, The Punisher will be looking to dish out a similar brand of punishment tomorrow night in order to keep his name circulating amongst the elite of the 147 crowd, a crowd right now that is the class of the entire sport hands down. And that's about all that makes this fight interesting on paper, the fact that Williams not only has to win but that he has to do it in spectacular fashion.
With that as his motivation, I see him getting the job done in style. Quintana is a B-lister at best whose only claim to fame is decisioning an overrated Joel Julio. Williams, meanwhile, is a veritable nightmare to fight, a ridiculously long and accurate southpaw who's unnaturally quick and agile for such a tall welterweight, and who along with his manifest physical gifts possesses a sharp set of boxing instincts to boot. Basically, for your average 147, fighting Williams is like fighting some ungodly combination of Floyd and Kevin Garnett. There's a danger that he'll go after the stoppage too hard and get rocked a few times - this Puerto Rican is no Margarito, but he's a natural counter-puncher and he's got enough pop to get your attention. On that score, I think Williams' main obstacle tomorrow night will be keeping his mojo in check. I mean, here he is headlining an HBO card against an overmatched opponent and there's BIG-TIME money out there on the table for him if he can put on a laser show. Makes me think a little of Vicious Vivian Harris trying to make some fireworks by going after Carlos "I'm Gumby dammit" Maussa on the Floyd/Gatti undercard and shooting his wad in the first two rounds, ending up on the canvas in the 7th.
I don't think Williams will be so hasty, though, and even if he is it's hard to imagine him paying too big a price for it. He's got a good head on his shoulders and thus far has shown preternatural poise in big situations. My prognostification is that he'll take his time, and if he does that he should have him out of there between the 8th and 11th. A decision here is not out of the question, though - it would be a bad result for Williams, but it could happen. Myself, I'm rooting against it. So... Williams TKO10 Quintana. It is written.
As for Berto, well, he has something of the same situation and it's kind of a shame for the kid, because any other weight class, any other time, and I think he'd be on the verge of stardom right now. There's just so much damn traffic at 147 at the moment. He also got a bad break in his last fight, an unsung 2007 FOY candidate against David Estrada that should have generated a lot of more buzz on the whole but instead ended up a footnote to the all-time war that was Pavlik/Taylor.
Berto's past two fights have been real learning experiences for him - Cosme Rivera, who was the classic bump in the road for a young comer, that hard-headed veteran with a few tricks up his sleeve that every prospect has to get past at some point if they're going to graduate out of the minors, and then Estrada, a very talented B+/A- fighter who's hard as nails and fighting for his life. Now Berto is facing a different kind of challenge, a reported speed merchant from Germany, Michel Trabant, who is evidently a very savvy boxer. Something tells me his virtues are being oversold, however. I don't know him so I can't really say other than to offer an opinion based on the records, which is that a stoppage by Berto would send a definite message that he's ready for a shot at the A-list, while a convincing decision victory would be a solid par for the evening.



14 Comments:
Quintana is a B-lister
I like what you are doing over here at this blog...holla!
Your blog is my homepage.
Rooster, I've said it before and I'll say it again - I'm honored.
I got a post up over at the Sporting blog right now that I think you'll dig - http://www.sportingnews.com/blog/TheSportingBlog/135193/
Let me hotlink that shit - it's called More Cowbell, just to wet your whistle a little.
Large,
Virtuoso performance by Williams against Margarito? I assume that isn't equivalent to saying it was 'one-sided', as I thought that if Margarito didn't sleepwalk the first few rounds he could've pulled out the win.
But that was due to the fact that both of them are quite good. Williams did exhibit a non-stop high workrate, it was very impressive.
Man, Margarito is a great fighter and I had Williams winning 8-4. He dominated the first half and looked fantastic doing it, and then held on in the second half and fought a beautiful 12th to pull it out. There are much bigger names at 147 who might have a tougher time handling Margarito, if they could do it at all. Near-virtuoso I think is a fair assessment given the circumstances.
I'm not sure where Williams goes after this fight. He wants to chase the big names, of course, but who is really in the offing?
Cotto is booked more or less for the rest of the year. PBF is an unlikely to accept the risk/reward ratio Williams represents.
Shane may be a possibility late in the year, assuming he takes care of Zab. The only other option really is the loser of Margarito/Cintron (the winner of course will go on to fight Cotto). But Williams may not like the optics of taking the loser of that bout, though he may relish the chance to get the fight with Cintron that he was denied.
Maybe the most likely, albeit least desirable, result is that Paul will get frozen out for a year or so.
As Pavlik Fan mentioned, Williams seems to be caught in that same trap as Cotto. Not enough juice, too little reward, to get Money into the ring.
However, the glut of talent at 147 means that the various permutations of fighters should fill the next year or two with great fights while Money dicks around with DLH or the MMA or business or retirement. The true talent will rise, and this time next year we'll be salivating at PBF-Cotto or PBF-Williams.
Also, from a purely financial standpoint, the longer guys like Williams and Berto stay just-below-the-A-list, the better chance of seeing a great fight on HBO and not on PPV. Which is nice.
Agree with both Pavlik fan and El Mero. Very tough hustle for Williams right now, but it will pay off in the long run, and to be honest I think he could use the seasoning. Not sure he's ready for Cotto/Floyd level talent yet - as Matt points out, Margarito might have stopped him if it had been a 15-round fight. But I don't worry about the kid at all because I think he's got legs as far as starpower goes. He's beautiful to watch, is fast and dazzling but not so much so that he doesn't get tagged, and he's a big good-looking kid who looks like a basketball player. I see his star rising in a similar trajectory to Cotto if he's just keeps winning and fighting crowd-pleasing fights.
I'd be careful about fighting Sugar Shane, though, if I were him. No one in the game at 147 except for Floyd would beat the Shane that fought Cotto, and Shane has the perfect body and style to destroy Williams. Not sure how many of those wars Mosley has left in him, but I could definitely see him punishing The Punisher.
If Mosley is the only big name that Williams is able to being to the table I say go for it. Remember, Large, that Mosley in his prime had all sorts of trouble finding his rhythm against Vernon Forest. It went to show that Sugar can be taken off his game against rangy foes. Williams showed against Margarito that his best asset wasn't punching power or chin but his defense and the way he keeps fighters from getting good angles on him. If that fight were to happen I would probably see Mosley doing a lot of chaing but not a lot of landing.
I don't know Guy - one thing that worried about Williams in the Margarito fight was his pop. I thought he fought a beautiful fight, but he didn't hurt Margarito once in that thing, and Sugar Shane is at least as rugged as Antonio if not more so. I think Shane still has the mobility and the power to get close to Williams and bust him up inside. I'd like to see the fight though, no doubt, and you have a point - if that's what Williams has to do to up his profile, then maybe it's the right thing to do. Cotto had to walk that plank. I guess all I'm really saying is - it sure ain't no cakewalk.
OK, the Berto fight just ended, and I'm watching the pre-fight Williams stuff and something just doesn't seem right. Both fighters weighed in at 146-3/4 for the official weigh in... fine, its a welterweight draw... but they said that their "unofficial weigh in today, Williams weighs 164 and Quintana weighs 158.
When was this official weigh in, and how does someone put on 18 lbs since then? Is this fishy?
Whoa, what happened?
Williams would get smoked by Money, Cotto or even Mosley. He took a beating, he was big enough to take the beating, but a better fighter would KO him pretty easy.
Agreed... how could Lederman have scored it 115-113 Williams? I think he's slowly losing his mind.
Lederman was off his rocker, I guess HBO has(or had) big plans for Williams, but gimme a break.
Williams had no defense for the left hand, none at all. He got butchered really, a better pucher would have had him floored.
Post a Comment
<< Home