Might Makes Right

There simply cannot be anything in the history of sports to match this – two brothers fighting career-defining rematches in the space of two weeks, each fight a classic in its way, and each brother losing by the narrowest of margins that a fight can be lost, a single point on a single scorecard. Beware the ides of March indeed, or in the case of the snakebitten Marquez brothers, beware the whole goddamn month, for these first two weeks of March 2008 have brought them both excruciating disappointment.
I have to believe the lion’s share of that disappointment rests with the elder brother, Juan Manuel, after losing a split decision last night to Manny Pacquiao in a seesaw battle of skill and blood and unbelievable mettle. No one ever has suggested that the career of the younger, lighter Marquez brother has been one of missed opportunities and under-appreciation. But with Juan Manuel, such feelings have hovered around him ever since the aftermath of the first Pacquiao fight in 2004. Last night’s rematch was his shot at glorious redemption in the eyes of Mexico, the boxing world and the world at large. With the stakes so high, to lose by one point… on ONE scorecard… it’s hard to imagine the heartbreak.
Of course, like his brother before him, Juan Manuel has nothing to hang his head about today. The fight was a masterpiece from both corners and close as close could be, such that it’s literally hard to imagine a fight being much more even and great at the same time (well, except for that fight two weeks ago, with that other Marquez…). Amazingly, I had exactly the same score for Pacquiao last night that I did for Israel Vasquez – 114-113 – and I have to say, I felt more confident about that score than I did in Vasquez/Marquez III. Close as it was last night, I found the rounds easier to call. To my eyes, each fighter clearly won six rounds apiece, but of course in the third round Pac Man put JMM on his ass, and that was the difference right there.
What a punch it was too, the third-round blow that proved, as it were, the game-winning shot. As I remember it, Marquez lunged forward with a right hand and Manny slipped to his right, came up with a right hand of his own that was more of a feint than a punch, and then brought across a lightning-quick left hook right on the button of the still-lunging Marquez. JMM went down like he’d been shot. It wasn’t the type of kinetic straight left that we’re used to seeing Pacquiao knock people out with. It was a short precise hook that found a split-second opening, and the fact that it inflicted such momentary damage was quite a testament to something we’ve all known for a long time – Manny Pacquiao is one hell of a heavy puncher.
Marquez landed his share of big shots in the fight, even staggered Manny a few times, but he wasn’t able to land him on the canvas (not enough is written about Pac Man’s chin) because, thoughtful and accurate as he is with his punches, he just doesn’t have the pop. Also, a lot of the starch came out of his shots in the late rounds and that hurt his chances on the scorecards. He dominated the middle of the fight – I had him winning rounds five through eight – but in the ninth a cut above his right eye caused by a seventh-round headbutt opened into an awful gash, and as the claret flowed his energy level visibly dropped. On my card, he lost rounds nine through eleven (almost going down again in the tenth) and needed at least a knockdown to tie it up going into the final frame. Though he won the 12th cleanly (Harold Lederman, what are you watching?), all it earned him was that heartbreaking one-point margin of defeat.
The bout reminded me a lot of Cotto/Mosley, another fight contested at such a high level of skill and intensity as to be almost beyond comprehension. The concentration being brought to bear in that ring last night was unbearably palpable. I felt it emanating through my television screen and it made me nervous. I tell you, these are the kinds of fights that I relish, that for me make boxing such satisfying sporting spectacle – the chess matches that are also slugfests, and vice versa. That perfect mixture of brain and brawn. In the final analysis, each of these men is amply possessed of both qualities, although Marquez has a bit more brain and Pacquiao slightly more brawn. When you think about it, that’s a strikingly similar index to the Vasquez/Marquez breakdown. So what else is there to say in the end but… score another one for the brawn.




























